2026 New York Giants Fantasy Football Overdrafted, Underdrafted & Sleeper

The New York Football Giants, aka “the Giants that might not suck,” or “the other group of chuds called the Giants,” have a new head coach in town with, inexplicably, the more brainwormed of the two Harbrothers. He brought Greg Roman with him as an assistant, but put Patrick Mahomes Merchant Matt Nagy in charge of the offense. So, with that in mind, don’t draft any Giants. God bless and goodnight. Just kidding, let’s check out the 2026 New York Giants’ fantasy football sleeper, undervalued and overdrafted players!

Sleeper: Malachi Fields, Wide Receiver (WR84, Pick 217 OVR)

Fields is a massive nine-route specialist who isn’t particularly fast and who has the tightest hips that you have ever seen. He is a one-trick pony, and his trick is having a huge catch radius (and he is a pretty good blocker, so 1.5 tricks). Outside of that, he doesn’t create separation, is not a YAC guy, and doesn’t really transform any portion of the offense. He’s mostly a big-bodied outside receiver who is there to make Jaxson Dart’s life easier on third down, not to produce any sort of consistent fantasy points for your team, similar to how the 49ers used Jauan Jennings before he broke out.

There’s a chance for Fields to produce in this offense. I’m not super bullish on the talent, but I wasn’t incredibly bullish on Wan’Dale Robinson, either. The Isaiah Likely addition makes the offense more crowded, but there’s still a role for Malachi Fields, similar to how Jennings carved out a fantasy-relevant role for the 49ers a few years ago. The Malik Nabers factor also looms large, as he is not expected back for week one from his knee injury, but that doesn’t mean that he will be at 100% when he does return. It’s an interesting path to value for Fields, but he received the day two value that makes him worth looking at in redraft leagues (approximately 20% hit rate for top-100 wide receiver picks).

Undervalued: Isaiah Likely, Tight End (TE14, Pick 120 OVR)

The Theo Johnson Truthers are down bad and in shambles, as part of John Harbaugh’s Ravens influx included Isaiah Likely, who spent last season as the Ravens’ TE2, doesn’t have much to look at in his overall numbers from 2025: 27 receptions, 307 receiving yards, and one touchdown. However, he just wasn’t used much, taking a back seat to Mark Andrews.

However, he did produce when targeted. Likely had over five targets twice last season, and finished as TE9 and TE10 in those two games. These were his only top-ten finishes last season, and were a step back from the three he had in 2024. Over the last two seasons, there hasn’t been much under the hood for Likely, except that he’s ranked inside the top-ten in average depth of target among tight ends in each of the last two seasons.

The case for an Isaiah Likely breakout campaign does not sit in the last two seasons; it sits in the back half of 2023, when Andrews missed six games. In those six games, Likely was TE4, averaging 13.9 PPR points per game. He did this not by getting a lot of targets (4.7 per game), receptions (3.5), or yards (53.7). He did this because he scored five touchdowns in six games.

The path forward for Isaiah Likely is pretty clear: a blob tight end whose value will come thanks to a decimated wide receiver corps. His price is right for me at TE14, as he makes for one of the better options in a one-two punch at tight end late.

Overvalued: Jaxson Dart, Quarterback (QB9, Pick 91 OVR)

I regret to inform you that Jaxson Dart will be a top-ten quarterback this season, despite (or because of) his weaponry and his idiot offensive coordinator. Dart played over 5% of snaps in twelve games last season, and finished as QB11 or greater eight times. From week four (his first start) until the end of the season, he averaged 20.7 fantasy points per game, which ranked him as QB7 in fantasy points per game. All of this has to do with his rushing points, as he averaged just 189 passing yards and 1.25 touchdowns per game in his starts. However, he led the NFL in quarterback rushing yards from his first start to the end of the season, with 487 in 12 games. Kick in 9 touchdowns (third in multiple rushing touchdown games among quarterbacks, tied with Jalen Hurts and behind Josh Allen and Trevor Lawrence). A ton of these were designed, too, as his 47 designed carries ranked second behind Josh Allen’s 50.

Now, there’s the obvious “Brian Daboll was trying to physically snap him in half,” which is, to be fair, fair. But his nine rushing touchdowns intrigue me, as he only had seven goal-line carries. This is quite a bit for a quarterback, to be fair, but only four of his nine touchdowns came from inside the five-yard line, compared to Josh Allen (11), Jalen Hurts (6), Trevor Lawrence (5) and Daniel Jones (5). Dart isn’t just lining up and slamming it into folks at the goal line, which is the big concern (though at 6’2” 223, I’m not particularly concerned for Dart, as that’s Patrick Mahomes & Aaron Rodgers-sized, not exactly a stick out there).

I expect a slight step back from Dart in the rushing department, as he cannot continue to run with as much reckless abandon as he did last season. However, the Giants receiving corps should hopefully be better than last season, with Malik Nabers recovering from his ACL tear last year (…hopefully…) and the receiving corps hoping to get a modicum of production out of a bevy of offseason vet signings. That having been said, running is in Jaxson Dart’s DNA, and it’s in the Ravens’ DNA, which John Harbaugh is clearly trying to invoke, with Greg Roman coming over with him. So, I firmly believe that we will get a completely scammy top-ten season out of Jaxson Dart, with the “per game” caveat, as he is likely further to turn his brain into a slurry at some point this year.

Herein lies the rub: he’s going as QB9, and that’s his likeliest landing point, at least to me (I ranked him QB9 in our too-early ranks). Some are pegging him for the Drake Maye step forward in year two, but there’s one major difference between Drake Maye and Jaxson Dart: Drake Maye is good.

Ultimately, I doubt I will have any Jaxson Dart, unless he starts to slip. Taking QB9 at QB9 is the ultimate way to finish in sixth place, because that pick does nothing for you.

Especially since my king (Trevor Lawrence) goes two quarterbacks later.

About Jeff Krisko

You can follow me on twitter, @jeffkrisko for the same lukewarm takes you read here.

View all posts by Jeff Krisko →

Leave a Reply