2026 New York Jets Fantasy Football Overdrafted, Underdrafted & Sleeper

The New York Jets are, understandably, one of the league’s laughingstocks. Their big move at quarterback was 95-year-old Geno Smith, but they have Breece Hall and a stock of young pass catchers after taking Omar Cooper Jr. and Kenyon Sadiq in the draft. Let’s take a look at the 2026 New York Jets’ fantasy football sleeper, undervalued, and overvalued players!

Sleeper: Kenyon Sadiq, Tight End (TE21, Pick 152 OVR)

Sadiq is a shredded, undersized, versatile tight end who Oregon used as a chess piece to find mismatches all over the field. He is a legit route runner, though he rounds off his breaks at times, floating to his spot rather than attempting to beat his defender to the point of attack. As such, he is better at pressing the holes in zones than he is juking a man defender. Luckily, given that he will mostly line up against linebackers and safeties, this isn’t something to worry about.

Outside of his route running and formation versatility, Sadiq is an extremely agile, frenetic tight end who attacks the ball at the point of attack and is a YAC monster. Despite being undersized, he is more than willing to scrap with defensive ends and slot corners alike. He’s undersized, but an all-around package. There’s some refinement available to him, too, which means that he likely hasn’t tapped his full potential.

The Jets are in a transitional period, which isn’t conducive to placing bets on them, but they do create wide-open opportunities. With Sadiq coming in and being the one learning the NFL, despite being more talented than Mason Taylor, he is likely to take a back seat to Taylor to begin the year. Think about Colby Parkinson and Tyler Ferguson in Los Angeles last year. Ferguson was undoubtedly the more talented tight end, but Parkinson was familiar with the system and took the lead in the room. Sadiq is unlikely to top seventy targets this season.

His most likely outcome is somewhere in the 75-target range, but he is a complete afterthought in drafts. I’m unlikely to make that click, but I am going to keep a close eye on Sadiq to see how he develops. With a wide-open skill core, the cream may rise to the top. That having been said, I do prefer his fellow rookie, Omar Cooper Jr.

Undervalued: Omar Cooper Jr., Wide Receiver (WR63, Pick 159 OVR)

Cooper isn’t much of a deep threat, but that isn’t where his bread is buttered, anyway. Cooper is the best receiver in this class at creating yards after the catch and one of the best at creating short-area separation, and those will be his calling cards in the NFL. That’s a strong calling card to have, as this type of game-breaking is extremely valuable to NFL teams. Cooper isn’t a burner, but he’s incredibly hard to bring down thanks to his great contact balance. So, he doesn’t waste time dancing around tacklers; he just lets them bounce off of him instead. If he does win downfield, it’s because of his ability to high-point a football, not because he burned anyone.

Cooper is a versatile receiver who lines up all over the field and is strong against press coverage. These two factors make him a boon for any team looking to draft him. He’s not without his warts, however, as he struggles with contested catches and is a complete zero in the run game.

Cooper is going to put Adonai Mitchell where he belongs (in the shadow realm) and give the Jets a true blue WR2 on their roster, and one who can work alongside a target hog like Garrett Wilson. I think this is a nice landing spot for Cooper in 2027 and beyond, since the Jets could move on from Wilson and make him WR1, or he could blossom with Wilson with a new quarterback, and really do something in 2027. But that passing game is playing out to be a mess this year. That having been said, as I mentioned with Kenyon Sadiq: this passing game is anyone’s guess, and Omar Cooper is far more talented than Adonai Mitchell, making him a decent deep league bet, especially since Frank Reich loves to spread the ball around.

Overvalued: Garrett Wilson, Wide Receiver (WR17, Pick 37 OVR)

The Jets are a bad passing game, finishing with under 3500 passing yards in two of the last three seasons (their non-Aaron Rodgers seasons). Despite this, Wilson has been… mostly fine, averaging 13.7 PPR points per game over the last three seasons, and finishing as WR15 per game in 2024 and WR17 per game in 2025 (though last year he was limited to seven games due to injuries). He is currently going off the board as WR17, despite being mostly a volume merchant who thrived on being the only game in town (which he is no longer). In 2025, he was second in target share and third in air yards share. In 2023, his last non-Aaron Rodgers season, he was seventh in target share and eighth in air yards share. In 2024, the offense was more prolific, so his share went down, but he was still top-20 in air yards and fourth in targets.

So, the passing game is low volume, and Garrett Wilson has thrived thanks to being the only game in town (without Aaron Rodgers), and the Jets added Geno Smith and two rookie pass catchers. The answer is to keep him in the same spot, even though everything that made him work is falling by the wayside. I am out on Garrett Wilson in redraft leagues, though I still believe in the talent long-term. This year, however, he is mostly going to disappoint fantasy managers.

About Jeff Krisko

You can follow me on twitter, @jeffkrisko for the same lukewarm takes you read here.

View all posts by Jeff Krisko →

Leave a Reply