2026 Arizona Cardinals Fantasy Football Overdrafted, Underdrafted & Sleeper

Jeremiyah Love

The Arizona Cardinals are a team adrift; their quarterback situation is in flux, with Jacoby Brissett potentially not fitting their tanking protocol. They also took a running back in the top three and had a breakout wide receiver that we still aren’t sure if we should trust. Let’s take a look at the 2026 Arizona Cardinals’ fantasy football sleeper, undervalued, and overvalued players!

Sleeper: Jeremiyah Love, Running Back (RB13, Pick 24 Overall)

It’s hard to call the number three overall pick in the real-life NFL Draft (the highest since Saquon Barkley went second in 2018) a sleeper, but here we are. Jeremiyah Love isn’t the prospect that Ashton Jeanty was last season, but Jeanty’s fall from grace has folks hesitant about clicking the button on Love earlier than the second or third round. I completely understand the instinct to fade Love after Jeanty failed to live up to expectations last season. Still, Jeanty’s situation was so bad that they sacked the head coach, the offensive coordinator, and the quarterback, and also backed up a Brinks truck to the top interior lineman on the market.

That isn’t to say that Love has a great situation, but even with Jeanty disappointing, he still finished as RB11 last season in a worse team context. For example, the Linderbaum addition drags the Raiders up to the consensus 24th-ranked line, and the Cardinals start 20th. Not a world-beating line, but also not the worst on the planet. To put it differently, the yards before contact difference between the Cardinals and Raiders last season amounts to an extra 140 rushing yards alone. Add in the other team context (the Raiders had no quarterback as good as Jacoby Brissett and no receivers as good as Marvin Harrison Jr. or Michael Wilson), and Love is in a much better position to produce than Jeanty was last year.

I believe the situation stems directly from the Jeanty situation, and the two are not analogous at all. He’s not really a sleeper, per se, but he is a good value because drafters fear the Jeanty situation repeating itself in the desert.

Undervalued: Michael Wilson, Wide Receiver (WR41, Pick 94 Overall)

A lot of folks out there want to denigrate what Michael Wilson did last season by putting his splits with and without Marvin Harrison Jr. It is a bit disingenuous to do this, as it includes the games in the first half of the season before the Cardinals’ third-year wideout put it all together. After his breakout game in week eleven against the 49ers, Wilson and Harrison Jr. played three games together. In those three games, Wilson had 20 combined targets and had 36, 52, and 89 yards, scoring a touchdown in two of three games. While it’s a tiny sample size, it does speak for itself that the Michael Wilson breakout wasn’t an isolated incident. Those 59 yards per game ranked 22nd in those weeks, and his targets per game ranked 25th. Among wide receivers who ran at least 25 routes per game in those weeks, his yards per route run ranked 18th of 43 wide receivers. His breakout was for real, and he sustained it even when Marvin Harrison returned. It was for real, and while he isn’t top ten, he is an easy top-30 receiver going as a bench player.

Overvalued: Marvin Harrison Jr., Wide Receiver (WR31, Pick 66 Overall)

Marvin Harrison Jr. has had one 100-yard game since week two of his rookie season, when he had the craziest first ten minutes of a game you’ll ever see (130 yards, two touchdowns), and none of them came last season. Here’s the simple fact of the matter, too: he wasn’t good last year. He finished as WR37 in fantasy points per game, and finished top-24 in just half of his games. That’s not too bad, usually, but he finished outside the top-50 in five of his twelve games. So, that is to say, he was actively unusable as often as he was usable. And there isn’t an under-the-hood metric that could make you excited about MHJ, either. TWO designed targets all year, 55th in red zone target share, 30th in air yards share, 46th in yards per route run, 42nd in yards per team pass attempt, and 33rd in yards per target. There’s just… nothing there to bet on for MHJ, but he’s going as WR31. I’d rather roll the dice on Michael Wilson 2.5 rounds later.

About Jeff Krisko

You can follow me on twitter, @jeffkrisko for the same lukewarm takes you read here.

View all posts by Jeff Krisko →

Leave a Reply