The Arizona Cardinals took, perhaps, the best player in the 2026 NFL Draft (and most certainly the best offensive player in the draft) with Jeremiyah Love. After that, however, things got a little iffy on the fantasy football front, as they get a potential low-ceiling successor to Jacoby Brissett in the desert in Carson Beck, and tall, fast vertical threat in Reggie Virgil. Let’s break all three down for 2026 fantasy football redraft leagues as we kick off our ninth annual Rookie Roundup series, as we always do, with the Arizona Cardinals.
Round 1, Pick 3 Overall: Jeremiyah Love, RB
The following is an excerpt from my Round One Rookie Roundup, which you can find here.
TALENT
First and foremost, I like Jeremiyah Love. Don’t put in the paper that I don’t like Jeremiyah Love. But…
Over the last few years, we have seen some prospect freaks come out at running back, namely Bijan Robinson and Ashton Jeanty. They both ticked every single box that you would want out of a running back. They had speed, size, control, power, vision, everything. While Jeremiyah Love is an exceptional running back, he is just a tick below both of those guys for me.
Let’s start with the rushing ability and the good. He is one of the most patient running backs that you will ever find, which, combined with his ability to decelerate into slow motion and accelerate through a hole at a level I haven’t seen since Le’Veon Bell, makes him one of the best backs to maximize good blocking ahead of him (or even poor blocking). He can turn a three-yard hole into a six-or seven-yard hole. He does a great job of watching the big uglies up front create space for him, then blasting through that space.
When he runs, he is a springy jackrabbit, a description you usually save for guys who give up 20 pounds to Love. Each step feels like he is already at full speed and somehow tapping into a new gear, as he deftly blasts downfield, using his momentum to fall forward on nearly every run. He’s a demon in space, and if he has space, he can take it an extremely long way. If there’s traffic… well… we will get to that in a second.
He’s also a very good pass catcher, naturally catching the ball away from his body and turning upfield, ready to get yards after the catch. He lines up out wide, but he’s usually resigned to bubble screens, drags, and curls.
Now, for the bad. While his vision is exceptional at the line of scrimmage, he runs like he’s wearing a dog’s medical cone; he has almost no peripheral vision, often focusing just on juking the guy in front of him, which leads him into big hits from defenders he didn’t even know were there (Velociraptors hunting would take him out in a hurry). He also struggles with traffic because of this, often spinning straight into a defender (or a blocker) and cutting his run short. Love also struggles to stack moves because of this, mostly just playing on pure gut instinct and athleticism. Sometimes it will work, but every run feels like the Saquon Barkley reverse-hurdle run, where his athleticism bails him out of barely-controlled chaos threatening to get him blown up at a moment’s notice.
All in all, I am in on Jeremiyah Love, but I don’t put him at the same tier as Bijan. Being alongside Jahmyr Gibbs isn’t worth crying over.
NFL Comparison: Jamaal Charles
Draft Grade: Round 1
2026 OPPORTUNITY
This was a baffling decision by the Arizona Cardinals, as they have much bigger needs. They added Tyler Allgeier and retooled James Conner’s contract to keep him around, too. They really didn’t need to do this, especially since they are likely hitting their nadir, and Love is unlikely to be a part of the next good Arizona Cardinals team.
That having been said, he not only is already miles ahead of every other running back on that team, but his profile already has virtually zero overlap with the existing players, meaning that he’s unlikely to get shunted into a timeshare situation with the other running backs there. The blocking ahead of him is going to be suspect, but not quite at 2025 Ashton Jeanty levels. The Cardinals last season ranked fifteenth in ESPN’s pass block win rate, were tied for twelfth in stuff rate, and were twentieth in yards before contact per attempt. So, the situation is not great, but not dire.
2026 FANTASY FOOTBALL OUTLOOK
Somebody in your draft is likely to get rookie fever and possibly overdraft him in the first or early second round, but at first blush I would take him in the second or third round. That feels like a good sweet spot for him, and he is likely to get every chance to dominate that backfield, giving him a high floor. But, I wouldn’t take him before RB7 off the board (Robinson, Gibbs, McCaffrey, Taylor, Achane, Cook, and Jeanty). But, once we get around RB8, things get interesting. I fully expect him to produce in his rookie year, but I am worried about the Cardinals’ offense’s overall potency. They scored plenty of points last year, but almost all of them were in catch-up mode, which is not conducive to fantasy football production. Still, he is unlikely to end the year outside of the top fifteen at the position unless there are some real surprises.
Round 3, Pick 65 Overall: Carson Beck, QB
TALENT
There are three main parts of playing quarterback: processing, pocket navigation, and actually throwing the football. Beck ticks two of those boxes, but boy howdy does he not tick the third. There’s a lot to like about Beck’s game. He has a ton of poise in the pocket, navigates well, progresses through his reads quickly, and keeps his head downfield. Beck also does an excellent job of pre- and post-snap reads, frequently dissecting the defense and finding the right place to put the football.
Unfortunately, once he cocks back, that’s when the problems start. Beck has a long, wide, looping motion, whereas most quarterbacks recommend a tight motion to create consistent action and a clear sense of where the football will go. Beck’s looping motion causes several issues. First, the balls are just. So. Slow. They take forever to get out of his hands, frequently allowing defenders to catch up with the pass. Second, the balls die on Beck; even short and intermediate balls travel in a shallow arc rather than “on a rope.” This makes it difficult for players to catch the ball on the run and gain yards after the catch, though numerous plays in the Miami offense were built around YAC.
Third, and most importantly, his looping, irreplicable motion makes balls fly all over the place on Beck. It’s a real mess watching him try to throw the football, which is what makes him a project quarterback in the 2026 NFL Draft, one that is unlikely to have an impact in his rookie season.
I see the projectability if he can just fix that stupid motion. It’s the same problem that I had with Brock Purdy in the predraft process, and it’s the same thing that he fixed to make him a top-ten passing quarterback in the league. Beck doesn’t have that upside, but he could fix himself into being a Davis Mills-level backup quarterback.
NFL Comparison: Tommy DeVito
Draft Grade: Round 5
2026 OPPORTUNITY
This is an interesting situation for Beck and the Cardinals, because Jacoby Brissett knows that he is on his last hurrah and is trying to maximize his last chance at a big payday. He is currently holding out (from unofficial camps), hoping to squeeze some more cash out of the Cardinals. That having been said, Brissett was a fun quarterback last year, even though he didn’t turn on the fantasy points machine until the Cardinals were already down large.
Given the current tone and tenor of the 2027 NFL Draft class, and the fact that the Cardinals were already bad enough to draft third in a class that virtually forced them to take Jeremiyah Love as the highest running back taken since Saquon Barkley, they likely run it back with the “fun but bad” formula in 2026. There will come a point where the local radio broadcast will have jokers on the line calling for Beck, but even if that happens, I doubt he gets more than a few starts at the end of the season.
2026 FANTASY FOOTBALL OUTLOOK
There isn’t really a reason to draft Beck outside of, like, the early third round of 2QB dynasty drafts. I have zero interest in drafting him, even in 2QB leagues as a stash. When he plays, he likely keeps his extremely low ceiling, making him virtually useless for fantasy football purposes.
Round 5, Pick 143 Overall: Reggie Virgil, WR
TALENT
Reggie Virgil is a tall, svelte receiver who is a good deep ball tracker and an aggressive route runner. He has good focus and hands at the catch point, and has good adjustment to the football. Virgil is also a pretty decent weapon, as he is capable of taking a jet sweep all the way, and he is a demon with the ball in his hands, making him a perfect big play threat. Unfortunately, he struggles with bigger corners knocking him off his route, and he can’t shake defenders on go routes. He plays faster than his 4.57 would indicate, but ultimately, he is a gadget player until I see otherwise.
NFL Comparison: Robbie Chosen
Draft Grade: Round 5
2026 OPPORTUNITY
I don’t see a world where Reggie Virgil gets enough volume to do anything, though he likely finishes his rookie season as a wind sprint all-star. The Cardinals will have Marvin Harrison Jr., Trey McBride, Michael Wilson, and Jeremiyah Love ahead of him in the pecking order on offense, at least, and are set to be one of the worst teams in the NFL.
2026 FANTASY FOOTBALL OUTLOOK
If you’re feeling froggy in round nineteen of your best ball drafts, and you have a Cardinals stack, he likely pops into your lineup once or twice, when he catches a deep ball from Jacoby Brissett or takes a jet sweep forty yards to the house. But in redraft and even dynasty leagues, I don’t have much of an interest in Virgil.
