The Pittsburgh Steelers took my draft crush, Germie Bernard. But what other fantasy football-relevant players did they take in the draft?
Round 2, Pick 47 overall: Germie Bernard, WR
TALENT
If Kyle Shanahan could build a wide receiver in a lab, it would probably be Germie Bernard. He is a strong, versatile route runner who can take carries out of the backfield and block his rear end off. He’s a combination of pre-peak Deebo Samuel and current Jauan Jennings. Bernard can carry the ball, bully his defenders, and hand-fight with the best of them to get the football. He’s also a great YAC guy who can both dole out and receive punishment.
Bernard already shows NFL-level body control and foot placement, adjusting to poorly thrown passes and toe-tapping sideline throws easily. His main issue is that he does not have good long speed, and will mostly end up working underneath. But he will put in work underneath, and a lot of it. He is going to be a bully possession receiver, despite his size, and he is going to make a team very happy.
NFL Comparison: Thicc Robert Woods
Draft Grade: Late 2nd Round
2026 OPPORTUNITY
Well, this kind of stinks for #Germiephiles. Bernard likely starts the 2026 season third on the wide receiver depth chart, behind DK Metcalf and newcomer Michael Pittman Jr. in Pittsburgh, though there is a path to targets for the rookie early on. Germie Bernard is going to start the season as the slot receiver for Aaron Rodgers. He was about a 35% slot guy in college, and it would make sense to get the two beefers—DK Metcalf (2025 13.2% slot rate) and Michael Pittman (2025 31% slot rate)—on the outside.
An aside, I earned my em-dash creds, please don’t take that as generative AI BS. Anyway…
Bernard would fit into the Steelers as their WR3, but last season, they ran the third-fewest pass plays out of wide receiver sets. That would be a big, fat discouraging statistic for Germie, except Mike McCarthy runs plays there now, and the last two seasons that Mike McCarthy ran an offense, the Cowboys passed out of three wide receiver sets at the seventh-most (2023) and fourth-most (2024) times in the league. This all stacks up to a lot of encouraging revelations about Germie and his rookie campaign, at least from an opportunity standpoint.
2026 FANTASY FOOTBALL OUTLOOK
Bernard is going to finish inside the top-five among rookie wide receivers, behind two of the big three (Tate/Lemon/Tyson), and one of the Browns guys (Concepcion/Boston). He’s going cheap as all get out, as he is WR73 off the board. I am all in on Bernard at that price, given that you can just cut him if it doesn’t work out, and that he has top-36 upside for fantasy football purposes.
Round 3, Pick 76 Overall: Drew Allar, QB
TALENT
It’s rare to find a quarterback who isn’t really bad at anything, but I do not find anything that I particularly like on his game tape. Allar is a perfectly cromulent NCAA quarterback, but he will get eaten alive by NFL defenses, because everything is just about 20% insufficient.
Let’s start from the ground up: his base. He is all over the place with his footwork, and it makes it so that he doesn’t have a reliable, repeatable motion when throwing the football. This gives him a ton of trouble not only with accuracy, but most importantly, with ball drive. Allar fails to fire the ball into his target because he is a complete upper-half thrower. Ironically, his best throws come on the run, where a natural running motion forces him to throw through a planted foot, and he gets some drive on the ball. With as much leg drive as he gets in the pocket, he might as well be throwing while levitating 1” off the ground.
The short: his throwing motion is like a dad playing catch with his child, not an NFL-level quarterback. It also destroys any deep ball he might have.
This footwork mess also causes legitimate problems with short throws. Easy passes: screens, dumpoffs, slants, all turn into questionable efforts, because his footwork issues cause scattershot accuracy. Again, he’s all arm, which makes it extremely difficult to put the ball exactly where you want it. This is evident all over the tape.
Third, he must be part T. Rex, because defenders are completely invisible to him. At first, I thought it was an arrogant arm, but then I saw him straight up lollipop a ball to a defender standing no more than five yards from him. His post-snap processing is a major issue, and he struggles to see defenders; a median Mike Macdonald disguised look will put him in a fetal position.
Draft Grade: UDFA
NFL Comparison: Sean Mannion
2026 OPPORTUNITY
This is Aaron Rodgers’ last season, and you already know that he isn’t going to let his BFF Mike McCarthy bench him, even if the Steelers are out of it. You can ignore Allar.
2026 FANTASY FOOTBALL OUTLOOK
You won’t be saying, “allar be havin’ one of that then!” (sorry I’m sorry I’m trying to delete it)
Round 4, Pick 121 Overall: Kaden Wetjen, WR
TALENT/2026 OPPORTUNITY & FANTASY FOOTBALL OUTLOOK
Do not let his “wide receiver” billing fool you. Wetjen is a kick and punt returner, and had 23 catches for 197 yards and one touchdown across three seasons in Iowa. He isn’t there to be a wide receiver, he’s there to return kicks. So, you could guess how this would go if I did an opportunity & fantasy football outlook for him. You don’t have to remember his name for fantasy football; nice kick returner, though.
Round 5, Pick 169 Overall: Riley Nowakowski, TE
TALENT
Riley Nowakowski is if you gave a tight end C+ to B- skills at everything. He’s a well-rounded and proficient tight end, but nothing excites him, and he doesn’t have much in the way of a carrying trait. This is a skillset that could keep him in the league for a long time as a Garrett Celek-style individual. He’s good, but not great at any particular trait, while not having a lot of glaring deficiencies in his game, either. Unfortunately, his size is a big problem; Nowakowski stands just over 6’2”. Of all the players drafted in this class, Riley Nowakowski certainly is one!
NFL Comparison: Tyler Conklin
Draft Grade: 7th Round
2026 OPPORTUNITY
Nowakowski starts the season as the TE3 on the depth chart, behind longtime Steeler Pat Freiermuth and the $40 Million Man, Darrell Washington. This also puts him behind Germie Bernard, Michael Pittman, and DK Metcalf (not necessarily in that order) in the target pecking order. Also, Aaron Rodgers just wants to dump off the ball to running backs now. There isn’t much to take from Nowakowski’s opportunity this season.
2026 FANTASY FOOTBALL OUTLOOK
Nowakowski has no fantasy football value in 2026, or likely, beyond.
Round 7, Pick 230 Overall: Eli Heidenreich, RB
TALENT
Heidenreich is a wide receiver, but not quite. A running back, but not quite. Also, a fullback… but not quite. He played many roles in the fake Navy offense, and he measured well at the combine, which has a lot of fantasy football acolytes buzzing. He’s a fine, quick-twitch athlete, but he’s ostensibly a fullback who puts more go routes down than blocks. He doesn’t have any sort of defining trait other than being a quirked up little white boy. He’s Skattebo-esque in that regard, that he’s a high-energy player, but unlike Skattebo, he doesn’t really do anything. He just runs behind the defense a ton and… that’s it. That’s the whole game plan. That won’t fly at the next level. He throws some decent blocks against defensive backs, but he’s going to get put through the Earth the first time he tries that against Talanoa Hufanga or Kyle Hamilton. As it stands, he’s too small and too light to be a fullback, and his skillset doesn’t lead him into being much else, except maybe a pass-catching scat back in the right situation.
Draft Round: 7th Round
NFL Comparison: Skinny Kyle Juszczyk
2026 OPPORTUNITY
Here’s the thing about Heidenreich: I’m not sure that he is an NFL-level player, but that doesn’t stop everyone from getting all hot and bothered about him in fantasy football circles. The running back room ahead of him isn’t the sturdiest, but both Rico Dowdle and Jaylen Warren need to go down with injuries before the Steelers turn the room over to Heidenreich. I don’t see a world where (barring injury), Heidenreich finishes with more than eight touches per game in his rookie year. His skillset, however, could see those split between targets and carries. Some are pegging him for 4-5 targets a game off the bat, but whose targets do you take: DK Metcalf, Michael Pittman Jr., Germie Bernard, Rico Dowdle, Jaylen Warren, Pat Freiermuth, or Darnell Washington? That’s where I struggle to see a path forward for Heidenreich without injuries clearing up the room for him.
2026 FANTASY FOOTBALL OUTLOOK
I can see a dumber use of a 20th-round best ball pick. After all, Le’Veon Moss is retired! But I can’t see a reason to draft him in standard fantasy football leagues. Keep an eye on him in case of injuries, but there’s not much there, there.
