The Kansas City Chiefs took three backups in the 2026 NFL Draft: running back, wide receiver, and quarterback. Will they have fantasy football relevance in 2026?
Round 5, Pick 161 Overall: Emmett Johnson, RB
TALENT
Emmett Johnson is a north-south runner who doesn’t have great contact balance and who has some questionable footwork on counter runs. He also struggles to maximize the point of attack on holes opened by his offensive line. That having been said, he has exceptional lateral agility, though he gets hampered in the open field by bad vision, below-average creativity, and zero home run speed. Johnson possesses elite agility, but he knows that, and he spams it right into defenders.
Johnson is an above-average pass catcher, as well. Though he doesn’t run a varied route tree, he is more than capable of adjusting to poorly thrown balls, and immediately turning upfield with them. His path forward for fantasy football purposes is as a pass-catching back, like Theo Riddick or J.D. McKissic.
NFL Comparison: Dion Lewis
Draft Grade: Round 5
2026 OPPORTUNITY
The Chiefs have their next in the long line of backs that we fall for in the vaunted pass-catching back role that never does anything of significant value. The Chiefs lost Isiah Pacheco in the offseason, but replaced him with Super Bowl MVP Kenneth Walker III, and still have Brashard Smith, the most recent running back in the pass-catching back role that go nowhere. Johnson is a player I liked, depending on the situation, but the short area targets are all spoken for (should Rashee Rice not end up in prison, again), leaving very little for Johnson to do outside of two-minute drills.
2026 FANTASY FOOTBALL OUTLOOK
2026 was the first season of Kenneth Walker’s career that he didn’t miss multiple games, so there’s a path forward for Johnson in Walker’s absence. Given that he’s a part of the powerful Chiefs’ offense, he’s definitely worth an add if (…okay, when) Walker misses a couple of games. But, outside of that, I don’t see a big enough role for Johnson to do anything but have deep league desperation PPR flex appeal.
Round 5, Pick 176 Overall: Cyrus Allen, WR
TALENT
Cyrus Allen does a little bit of everything; he’s a good enough route runner to make it work, and he’s fast (4.4 40-yard dash), and does most of his damage out of the slot. He’s also preternaturally good at finding himself sprinting down the sidelines after getting to the edge, no matter how you get the ball in his hands. That having been said, he’s just not an exciting package when you put it all together. At the NFL level, he would have to find a way to work in a Rashee Rice-type role, maximizing his middle-of-the-field skills and stop-and-go skills to turn short passes into long touchdowns.
NFL Comparison: Jarvis Landry
Draft Grade: Round 4
2026 OPPORTUNITY
Well, well, well… how the turntables. Allen went to a team in the Chiefs who knows how to use a “Rashee Rice-type role” and Rashee Rice, as I write this, is currently behind bars nursing a fresh knee surgery, which screams, “Rashee Rice will miss 4-6 weeks after aggravating a poorly healed knee surgery,” or, “the NFL suspended Rashee Rice for four games, he will not appeal.” That will give Cyrus Allen a chance to produce this season, but only if Rice ends up out of his way. With a fully healthy and available Rashee Rice, unfortunately, there will be nothing left in the Chiefs’ offense for Allen.
2026 FANTASY FOOTBALL OUTLOOK
It’s a long shot for Allen to have fantasy football value, but the path exists. He’s a twentieth-round pick in best ball leagues, where you took Patrick Mahomes, and he’s on a rolodex of names that you keep an eye on in redraft leagues. But, he exists outside the rookie year wide receiver viability range (days one and two), so it’s an uphill battle for fantasy football relevance. Still, the opportunity exists, it’s just a very narrow and specific path to get there.
Round 7, Pick 249 Overall: Garrett Nussmeier, QB
TALENT
Nussmeier has good zip on his passes, and he does a good job of getting the ball to his weapons, provided that the defense gives him a nice, quick throw to exploit. Unfortunately, they’re on the field to prevent that from happening, and then all hell breaks loose for Nussmeier. He’s an aggressive gunslinger, but he doesn’t have any creativity to his game. He often stares down a receiver until he gets double- or triple-covered, and then he rifles the ball in there.
Nussmeier mostly grips-and-rips on gunslinging throws, because the offense was likely trying to contain his worst tendencies: he can’t process a defense to save his life. He predetermines his read, and then stands in the pocket long enough to make that read a goodish idea. That tendency to wait late into the play for something to develop is a nice trait to have, but it often led to Nussmeier getting blasted by defenders as the ball fluttered harmlessly to the grass.
Nussmeier doesn’t have a lot to his game, but could go on a Linsanity run if he gets a good coaching staff to quickly define reads for him, and give him a chance to just pepper his weapons with targets. He could start 3-4 games in a pinch, but don’t count on anything coming out of it unless he plays a terrible-tackling defense and has a bunch of weapons to do the hard part.
Draft Round: 7th
Pro Comparison: Nick Mullens
2026 OPPORTUNITY
The Chiefs anticipate the literal best quarterback of all time back from his knee injury in week one.
2026 FANTASY FOOTBALL OUTLOOK
Go outside, look elsewhere.
