Week three is in the books; the Raiders are 3-0, Case Keenum threw a touchdown to Kalif Raymond, and J.J. McCarthy is a Giant, just like we all predicted. There are three things we didn’t predict going into the season, and it’s time to take a look at some questions popping up in the fantasy football landscape after three weeks of glorious action.
Are the Lions a Pass Defense to Target?
On Sunday, the Detroit Lions ceded a 321-yard, three-touchdown, and zero-interception game to Geno Smith and the New York Jets. That wasn’t expected from the casual fan, but the Lions secondary has quietly been a bit of a mess this season. They had one primetime game where Josh Allen dog-walked them, but you could chalk that up to it being Josh Allen.
However, through three games, their pass defense is a complete mess. They allow the most fantasy points per game, and because they run up the score, the opponents get a ton of chances to throw the ball. While they gave up a ton of rushing to Josh Allen, they also gave up a ton of passing to all three quarterbacks this season, and you have to look no further than controlling for their opponents’ splits in and out of playing against them.
Geno Smith, Josh Allen, and Tyler Shough have played nine games total this season, with three of these going against the Detroit Lions. In three games against the Lions, these three quarterbacks averaged 326 passing yards, three touchdowns, and had two picks in three games (all by Tyler Shough before he went Super Saiyan). Over the course of a seventeen-game season, that would come out to 5,542 passing yards, 51 touchdowns, and 11 interceptions. That surpasses Peyton Manning’s record-breaking 2013 season in passing yards, and sit just four passing touchdowns behind that season.
If you compare that against how these quarterbacks performed outside of those games, they average 251 passing yards, 1.33 touchdowns, and 0.4 interceptions per game. That’s not the worst thing I’ve ever seen in my life, but it comes out to 4,269 passing yards, 23 touchdowns, and 9 interceptions; that is roughly 2025 Sam Darnold, but with 12 more passing yards per game and with slightly better ball security. Not to disrespect the champions (I’ll leave Marcus Mariota to that), but there’s a bit of a difference between Peyton Manning’s most prolific season and Sam Darnold JSN-maxxing to a Super Bowl.
So, ultimately, I am attacking the Lions with all the passing weapons that I can. So, look for a good bounce back next week for Bryce Young and the Panthers, and a fun second half for Jacoby Brissett and the Cardinals the following week. The Lions will start to get healthy again, so we should revisit after that, but it’s wheels up for the next couple of weeks.
Is Josh Downs A Must-Start Wide Receiver?
Josh Downs was one of the trendy sleeper wide receiver candidates this season, just like every other season of his career. This year, however, things are different. The Colts traded Michael Pittman in the offseason, thinking that they would instead turn to their newest $100 Million Man, Alec Pierce. Unfortunately, Alec Pierce was already hurt with a heel injury when they signed that contract, and he has already re-aggravated that ankle injury and is set to miss the next couple of months. In response to their dire wide receiver situation, the Colts pulled Keenan Allen off the scrap heap late into the offseason. Allen is facing a dual challenge of his own, being both washed and under the microscope for a potential DUI-related suspension.
That leaves Josh Downs as the only viable wide receiver for the Colts, and he’s lived up to that billing over the last couple of games, coinciding with the Alec Pierce foot injury aggravation. In week one, Pierce played on 59% of snaps, and Downs finished with four measly targets for two catches and 37 yards. Pierce played 17 snaps (26%) in week two before leaving the game with his injury. Over the last two games, Downs has 20 targets. He’s hauled those in for six catches for 75 yards per game over the last two contests, which is a 102-reception, 1267 yard pace.
There is only one thing giving me pause in calling Josh Downs a “must-start” wide receiver in two wide-receiver leagues: touchdowns. He has no touchdowns this season, and just eleven in his three prior seasons in the league. This is because Downs does not get targeted inside the 20-yard line, and definitely not in the end zone. He has one red zone target this season, and zero in the end zone. For his career, he has 42 red zone targets, but just eleven end zone targets (over 3+ seasons). He’s behind Marquise Brown, Tank Dell, Jahan Dotson, Allen Lazard, and Justin Watson in this statistic.
This is the only thing holding him back from being a must-start wide receiver in two wide receiver leagues. However, in three wide receiver leagues, I am firing him up and not looking back. The (lack of) touchdowns limit his upside, but you can’t find a better floor play right now than Josh Downs.
Do the Chiefs Have a New Reality for Rashee Rice, or is this a Sell-High Opportunity?
First of all, I want to remind everyone that Rashee Rice had an offseason knee cleanup procedure and immediately rehabbed in prison, so a slow start should probably be expected from Rashee Rice. With that in mind, let’s get into the numbers (after we slander some folks first).
There was much braying and gnashing of teeth among the fantasy football cognoscenti this season, as they were sprinting to declare themselves non-ball knowers and to call the “Rashee Rice PPR Scam” over. You had people declaring him “not ever good,” because they were ready to fire off takes before they were fully baked. Instead, we have a new era of Rashee Rice Football, one where he is actually used like a real wide receiver. The Chiefs have Kenneth Walker and Emmett Johnson now, so they don’t need Rashee Rice BS to be a load-bearing part of their offense, as it was in the past.
In his first three seasons, there was a lot of nonsense to Rashee Rice’s game; his average depth of target was 4.7 yards downfield, and 3.5 yards downfield on receptions. He mostly had short-area targets that the Chiefs used to simulate a run game. He averaged eight yards after the catch per reception, so it worked pretty well.
Through three games this season, things have completely changed for Rice. His average depth of target is 6.94 yards downfield (his closest peer is Drake London’s 7.00 aDOT), and his average depth of target on receptions is 5.5 yards downfield. His peers in this stat are guys like Khalil Shakir, Malik Nabers, and bona fide superstar Kalif Raymond. The depth of target doesn’t tell the whole story, either; he is tied for the lead among Chiefs’ wide receivers in target share, and his elusiveness still comes into play. His four missed tackles forced on the season ranks second, just behind Malik Nabers’ 5 (and he is tied with Ja’Marr Chase and Denzel Boston).
All of this has led to a very different stat-line for Rice, who is averaging 14.6 yards per reception and 11.2 yards per target. Both of these statistics are well above his career average of 11.8 yards per reception and 8.8 yards per target. He started off slow, with just two targets in week one, but over the last two weeks, he has 15 targets, 11 catches, and 171 yards. That pace would be 94 receptions for 1,453 yards. The new look Rashee Rice is rounding into shape, and he will still be a fantasy force. See if the Rashee Rice manager is buying into the “sky is falling” doomsayers, and trade for him if you can.
