The Tampa Bay Buccaneers are going to push Baker Mayfield out the door, but before they do that, let’s hope that he leads us to some fantasy football glory! Let’s take a look at the 2026 Tampa Bay Buccaneers’ fantasy football sleeper, undervalued, and overvalued players!
Sleeper: Ted Hurst, Wide Receiver (WR94, Pick 251 OVR)
I am really trying to make a nickname for Ted Hurst happen; could you help me with that? The definitely-not-overwrought nickname is “Drone Pilot” because his game is all screens and bombs. That having been said, he was an extremely productive player at Georgia State, despite the lower level of competition. Hurst is an athletic player with good acceleration in his routes and excellent ball tracking to make him a prime deep threat at the NFL level. Unfortunately, he lacks the heft to be a true three-level receiver; instead, he does his underneath work in the screen game and under low-depth-of-target chicanery. That having been said, he’s still a good (not great) blocker and should be in a team’s wide receiver rotation sooner rather than later at the NFL level.
If you draft a player like Hurst, you do it with a plan. Seemingly, the plan is to (further) shunt Jalen McMillan to the back burner with the Hurst pick. The already-deep wide receiver room adding Hurst with a day two pick screams “this is a plan for when Chris Godwin leaves,” but news out of rookie training camp indicates that Hurst could be in the plans for them sooner rather than later. This intrigues me, as the robust Buccaneers offense frequently produces multiple fantasy-relevant wide receivers. Hurst has a chance to be one of those receivers in 2026.
Ted Hurst is one of the players that I am not drafting until the end rounds of a draft, even if news out of camp is good. But he is a player that gives me some upside intrigue. He’s a good stash candidate as he gets the cheap and easy targets as well as the high-value, high-upside targets. He’s the cheapest of the drafted Buccaneers (WR101, pick 261 overall) by current best ball ADP, so if you end up with a Baker Mayfield, he’s the cheapest click you could make for a stack.
Undervalued: Baker Mayfield, Quarterback (QB18, Pick 124 OVR)
Baker Mayfield got “MVP” chants last season. That’s right, the guy that the Buccaneers are currently trying to screw around with contract negotiations was a very effective 2QB league quarterback before his shoulder injury. In the first ten games of the 2025 season, Baker Mayfield was QB11, averaging 236.5 passing yards per game with a 17:3 TD:INT ratio. He did this on the seventh-most air yards and with the tenth-most deep pass attempts. He was bombing it out, and the Buccaneers offense was doing well. The shoulder injury (and Emeka Egbuka hitting the rookie wall) derailed the offense. This year, he’s going well behind where he should be (around QB15) as a great 2QB league or best ball QB2. In redraft leagues, however, he probably shouldn’t go off the board. But, he had seven top-twelve finishes in his first ten games, so he should be in the streaming discussion immediately in a week one shootout against the Bengals.
Overvalued: Bucky Irving, Running Back (RB25, Pick 58 OVR)
To be fair, I see Bucky Irving as a backend RB2, so perhaps his price is spot-on, but I need to get my feelings out about Buccaneers Irving this season, and it’s that the Bucs have too dang many running backs in too dang many roles for Irving to truly thrive as a click that I enjoy making as my RB2.
Rachaad White left to the Commanders, and the Buccaneers immediately replaced him with Kenneth Gainwell, who is a better version of Rachaad White: a guy who probably shouldn’t carry the full load but who could be immensely useful as a part-time guy and a pass catcher. White wasn’t good, but he was thoroughly used by the Buccaneers, as he had the eleventh-most receptions and the twelfth-most routes run at running back last season. He also finished with seven goal-line carries. Hang onto that last bit for a fun reveal at the end. Anyway, White took the passing downs role, and he also had a handful of carries each game. All of which chipped away from the cheap PPR points that Irving could get you.
Then, you get into the Sean Tucker of it all. Tucker was the goal line back for the Buccaneers. He didn’t get the ball a lot (86 carries), but when he did get the ball, he got it around the goal line (seven goal line carries, and 22 red zone touches). He finished with eight touchdowns, mostly because the Buccaneers called his number the second they got in and around the goal line. Between White (now Gainwell) and Tucker, the Buccaneers doled out fourteen goal line carries.
Bucky Irving had zero. I can’t stand by getting a running back who isn’t going to get cheap targets or the goal line carries. The upside is extremely limited, unless the Buccaneers switch around their running back usage.
